Blog: Which do you need – a UX designer, game designer, or both?

The next weblog publish, until differently famous, was once written by means of a member of Gamasutra’s neighborhood.
The ideas and critiques expressed are the ones of the author and now not Gamasutra or its guardian corporate.


A brand new occupation has just lately gave the impression: UX dressmaker, this is to mention Consumer eXperience dressmaker.

If we discuss consumer revel in, we’re on the center of the sport and that’s the area of the sport dressmaker. So who do you want: A UX dressmaker? A sport dressmaker? Each ?

Let’s get started by means of describing the contribution of those two professions within the manufacturing of a online game.

In all studios of the sector, the sport dressmaker is answerable for defining what gamers will revel in, how they’ll engage with the sport international, the ideas to be had to them, their rewards and the mechanisms that can cause them to wish to transfer ahead within the sport. The sport dressmaker is subsequently answerable for what the participant will revel in within the total sport, the “large image”.

For the majority of studios that best have one or two sport designers operating on a sport, they paintings as administrators or administrators. In brief, a sport dressmaker is subsequently meant to be in particular focused on the consumer revel in. So why did the occupation of UX dressmaker rise up?

The will arose with loose video games. The latter face a serious problem, non permanent retention. For these kinds of video games, two-thirds of gamers who find a loose sport for the primary time by no means come again. That is all of the extra irritating for the writer because the expense of obtaining new gamers is now and again very prime.

Why are retention charges so low? The reason is in line with the psychology of the gamers: If they don’t put money into a purchase order, no attachment is created between the gamers and their sport. So, if the primary couple of minutes of a sport don’t seem to be fascinating, chances are high that they’ll forestall enjoying and not go back.

All of us remember examples of video games that we ditched because of a run of the mill educational, slow gameplay, loss of a stimulating non permanent objectives, overly competitive monetization, or loss of originality.

The publishers then learned that the design of the primary mins of play and the primary periods will have to be “chiseled” with nice care. If this subject pursuits you, I invite you to learn my weblog at the First Time Consumer Enjoy to find just right practices on this space.

On the other hand, some sport designers centered best at the sport mechanics, the “large image”, and positioned too little significance at the design of the primary mins of gameplay.

Publishers of free-to-play video games also are confronted with every other well known drawback: Just a small fraction of gamers make any acquire. How do you persuade them to put money into a loose sport?

Once more, sport designers didn’t all the time remember that their function had modified. While in conventional video games, this is, paid video games, the one fear of sport designers is the “a laugh” of the gamers, without spending a dime video games, their considerations are the “a laugh” of the gamers AND their monetization.

It was once then that the UX designers gave the impression.

Impressed by means of cognitive science, UX design specializes in the main points of what gamers see and really feel. UX designers will search to put across “messages” to gamers thru shapes, colours, sounds and navigation within the sport interface. This emphasis on ergonomics, at the discovery of the sport, at the first gratifications of the gamers, gave their position to UX designers. The latter introduced a technology that many sport designers didn’t have.

A UX dressmaker will make finding and working out a sport extra relaxing and not more worrying. It’s going to additionally inspire, in a kind of manipulative means, gamers to make a purchase order in a sport.

The builders additionally learned that UX design too can assist give a boost to PC or console video games that don’t seem to be intended to be loose. Right here too, the enhanced ergonomics, interfaces and studying of the sport make sense.

That stated, seasoned sport designers already do this and contact onboarding this a part of design. UX designers didn’t invent the whole thing!

So I come again to the unique query; do you want a sport dressmaker, a UX dressmaker, or each? It is all concerning the method.

In case you have a small workforce, your sport dressmaker (s) must have sufficient elementary wisdom to construct right kind onboarding and perceive the restrictions of monetization. In the end, give a boost to their technology by means of coaching them. Another way, you’ll all the time usher in an outdoor guide.

In case you have more cash, it can be smart to specialize your design workforce: Recreation designers will focal point on sport mechanics whilst UX dressmaker will paintings on onboarding and ergonomics.

In spite of everything, are you able to best use UX designers? It will be a dangerous selection. Actual sport designers are educated to expand mechanics that can upload pastime on your sport in the end. Additionally they know the way to get out of pre-established patterns to construct a brand new revel in. Recreation designers paintings like authors: they do not simply follow “recipes”, they provide their video games a singular coloring, an inspiration, briefly, they put a bit of of themselves into it. That’s how they may be able to create that pleasure that everyone knows.


Image credit score: 300_librarians


My earlier weblog entries on manufacturing and sport design problems:

Easiest practices for a a hit FTUE (First Time Consumer Enjoy)

Is it nonetheless value for indie builders to submit a sport on cellular platforms?


Pascal Luban

Inventive director & sport dressmaker, freelance

24+ years of revel in serving studios and publishers

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *