At the floor, Roku and Amazon Fireplace TV have so much in not unusual. Each be offering reasonably priced streaming avid gamers that you simply that you’ll be able to plug into almost any flat-panel TV, and each will mean you can get right of entry to a variety of widespread streaming services and products, from Netflix and Hulu to YouTube TV and Disney+.
Digging somewhat deeper finds some giant philosophical variations between the 2 streaming platforms: Roku’s tool emphasizes simplicity over flashy options, whilst its expansive hardware lineup tries to hit each imaginable finances. Amazon takes the other manner, pairing a small collection of simple-yet-effective hardware choices with a sprawling tool interface.
There’s no transparent winner between those two approaches. As an alternative, opting for between Roku and Fireplace TV as your streaming platform of selection will likely be a question of private choice. To make the verdict somewhat more straightforward, let’s stroll via how the 2 hottest streaming platforms evaluate.
Ease of use
Should you’re used to the speculation of launching apps to your telephone, you’ll be beautiful comfy the usage of a Roku software. Its major menu gifts a grid of icons, letting you briefly release streaming apps comparable to Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon High Video. And whilst you’re getting arrange, it’s simple to search out the preferred apps throughout the “Channel Retailer” segment of the house display.
The Fireplace TV menu is a lot more cluttered. As an alternative of a unmarried app launcher, there are separate rows for favourite and up to date apps, together with a grasp app checklist you’ll be able to get right of entry to by way of maintaining down the house button. The house display could also be surrounded by way of additional menus for films, TV presentations, and apps, every with its personal layers of advisable movies. There’s some benefit to this manner, which I’ll describe within the subsequent segment; however in comparison to Roku, it’s more difficult to navigate.
Content material discovery
The turn facet is that Amazon’s Fireplace TV interface is best at suggesting what to observe with out making you soar out and in of various apps. Stay scrolling previous the app checklist, and also you’ll to find row upon row of instructed films and presentations to observe. Maximum come from Amazon’s personal High Video provider, however you may also get suggestions from different apps, comparable to Netflix or HBO Now. Whilst this manner can really feel inscrutable—most commonly as a result of Amazon doesn’t mean you can customise the suggestions that seem—it’s useful for the ones instances whilst you’re feeling indecisive.
Roku’s makes an attempt at content material discovery are a lot more conservative. There’s a “Featured Loose” segment at the house display that spotlights unfastened films and TV presentations to observe, however that doesn’t assist if you wish to know what’s new on Netflix or Hulu. And whilst Roku gives editorially-curated “zones” for various genres, you must seek and drill although a number of menu layers to get right of entry to them. Consequently you’ll more than likely spend extra time within the apps you already know very best as a substitute of finding what else is in the market.
Merit: Fireplace TV
Apps and content material variety
Each Roku and Fireplace TV make stronger each main streaming provider and an extended checklist of area of interest ones, so this shouldn’t be a big house of shock. (The Fireplace TV’s greatest omission used to be an reliable YouTube app and YouTube TV make stronger, however either one of the ones arrived at the platform previous this yr.)
Nonetheless, Roku will get a slight edge for providing The Roku Channel, a unfastened app with a rising choice of ad-supported films and TV presentations. Roku not too long ago added kids’s movies to the apps, and it’s been increasing its lineup of unfastened reside “channels,” comparable to ABC Information, Filmrise, WeatherNation, and MGM Sci-Fi.
Voice keep an eye on
There’s no contest in this one. Whilst each platforms can help you seek by way of voice, Fireplace TV means that you can release movies and song immediately via its voice far off in extra services and products than Roku does, together with Netflix and Amazon High. It additionally helps tuning to reside channels in some streaming services and products, and when you have an Echo speaker, you’ll be able to release films and presentations with out even touching your far off. (Roku does make stronger hands-free controls with Echo and Google House audio system, however the syntax is clunky and the controls are restricted.) Amazon’s Alexa assistant additionally permits you to keep an eye on good house units, ask normal questions, or view safety digicam feeds the usage of the Fireplace TV far off, which isn’t an choice on Roku avid gamers.
Merit: Fireplace TV
Hardware: Streaming avid gamers
Amazon’s Fireplace TV software lineup is beautiful straight forward. If you wish to have the most cost effective streaming software and will tolerate slow efficiency, get the $40 Fireplace TV Stick (although I’d advise towards it). For a lot quicker efficiency and 4K HDR video make stronger, you’ll be able to spend a bit of extra at the $50 Fireplace TV Stick 4K. If you wish to have the most efficient efficiency and hands-free Alexa voice keep an eye on integrated, get the $120 Fireplace TV Dice.
Roku, in the meantime, these days gives six streaming avid gamers. I’d recommend staying clear of the $30 Roku Categorical and $40 Roku Premiere, as they each use infrared remotes that may really feel unresponsive and don’t have TV quantity or energy controls integrated. The Walmart-exclusive Roku Categorical+ is a better choice for 1080p playback, whilst the $50 Roku Streaming Stick+ hits the candy spot for 4K HDR. Easiest Purchase additionally sells a variant of the Streaming Stick+ with a headphone jack on its far off for $60, and if you wish to have USB and ethernet ports together with programmable far off buttons, the Roku Extremely will set you again $100.
In spite of all the ones choices, Roku doesn’t be offering a unmarried fashion with Dolby Imaginative and prescient, HDR10+, or Dolby Atmos decode (which is needed to get Atmos make stronger in Netflix). Amazon’s Fireplace TV Stick 4K and Fireplace TV Dice make stronger all off the ones issues. Fireplace TV units also are higher at remembering your house in fresh apps, while apps on Roku all the time restart after you go out them. So long as you steer clear of the finances Fireplace TV Stick, Amazon’s platform delivers a greater hardware price.
Merit: Fireplace TV
Hardware: Good TVs
Should you’d fairly purchase a TV with integrated streaming options as a substitute of a separate participant, Roku features the merit. You’ll to find Roku TVs with a variety of options, sizes, and costs from an extended checklist of distributors, together with TCL, Sharp, Hisense, RCA, and Walmart’s Onn emblem. And in contrast to with Roku’s standalone avid gamers, a few of these TVs do make stronger Dolby Imaginative and prescient HDR.
By way of comparability, TVs that run Amazon’s Fireplace TV tool handiest come from Easiest Purchase’s Insignia emblem and Toshiba in america, with a narrower vary of display sizes and lines. Desire a 75-inch TV with 4K HDR and quantum dots? You’ll be able to get one with Roku tool, however no longer with Amazon’s Fireplace TV running gadget on board.
Should you’re the kind of one who loves to tinker with their tech, you’ll to find extra to understand within the Fireplace TV platform. As it’s in line with Android, you’ll be able to sideload apps that aren’t to be had in Amazon’s retailer, comparable to Kodi, and you’ll be able to hook up a Bluetooth controller for gaming. Roku is extra of a closed gadget, and whilst you’ll be able to set up non-public channels that come from out of doors Roku’s personal retailer, the choices are a lot more restricted.
Fireplace TV additionally gives extra choices for integrating with an over-the-air antenna: Amazon’s Fireplace TV Recast hardware, for example, whilst a Channels DVR setup can play reside or recorded channels at local broadcast high quality. Neither of the ones choices are to be had on Roku avid gamers, although you’ll be able to nonetheless use Tablo, Emby, or Plex DVR as a substitute.
Verdict: Fireplace TV
Lengthy-term make stronger
Through the years, Roku has established a powerful monitor file for supporting older hardware, as streaming avid gamers and good TVs from 2014 onward proceed to obtain new apps and lines. Amazon’s Fireplace TV platform hasn’t been round for as lengthy, but it surely’s already left a slew of streaming units in the back of on older variations of Android. Whilst this hasn’t made a big distinction on the subject of options, it doesn’t bode as neatly for long-term app make stronger.
In each instances, alternatively, app makers may just nonetheless choose to not make stronger older hardware, without reference to Roku’s or Amazon’s personal make stronger. YouTube TV, for example, doesn’t paintings with the unique Fireplace TV or Fireplace TV Stick, nor does it make stronger positive older Roku fashions.
As a result of Roku is more straightforward to make use of, it has a tendency to be my default advice for someone who’s new to the streaming area, doesn’t have any current affinity for Amazon merchandise, and simply desires a cast streaming participant for inexpensive. Should you don’t thoughts extra of a finding out curve, alternatively, you’ll be able to accomplish much more with a Fireplace TV software, and the Fireplace TV Stick 4K particularly stays the most efficient price within the streaming participant trade.
Simply don’t overthink it an excessive amount of, as you’ll more than likely be at liberty slicing the cable TV twine with both one.