Harry Maguire: Why his Greek trial went so fast

Harry Maguire (C, blue cap) leaves a court building on the island of Syros, Greece, 22 August 2020Symbol copyright

Greek justice threw the ebook at Harry Maguire, and rapid.

His global soccer profession used to be placed on cling after a court docket gave him a suspended prison time period, for repeated physically hurt, tried bribery, violence in opposition to public staff and insult after arrest on Mykonos.

He has now appealed, and is now presumed blameless except the enchantment court docket reveals him accountable.

Why used to be it so fast to get a conviction?

In part as a result of, within the eyes of Greek justice, he used to be “stuck red-handed”.

“In Greek felony process there’s a procedure referred to as “in flagrante delicto” and it applies to other folks stuck within the act of committing an offence,” says Athens attorney Konstantinos Starantzis. In different phrases, in this type of case it is utterly standard.

For as much as 48 hours from the time of an alleged offence – till nighttime the following day – police can arrest any individual with no warrant.

Then, after a initial investigation, the suspect will have to be introduced prior to a public prosecutor, who will make a decision whether or not to indict or now not. If there is an indictment, a tribulation will have to happen both the similar day or the day after.

Why have been there such a lot of fees?

In Greece, as anyplace else, resistance to arrest and violence in opposition to law enforcement officials, if confirmed at court docket, isn’t simply tolerated.

The Syros court docket used to be satisfied that there used to be some form of violence in opposition to the policemen concerned within the case for 2 causes:

  • The policemen would have had no authentic or affordable motive to persecute Maguire and his buddies
  • The officials introduced proof in their accidents

Within the eyes of the judges, Harry Maguire dedicated each offences, plus that of tried bribery, so they only passed him a related sentence.

Is it peculiar for this type of case to visit court docket?

Booze brawls on standard Greek islands are a commonplace prevalence right through the summer season.

Greek government have little interest in both hurting the rustic’s tourism or including extra circumstances to an already pressured justice machine. The explanation why this example made it to court docket used to be just because it concerned allegations of violence in opposition to policemen.

Did Maguire get an even trial?

It sounds as if each due procedure and the guideline of regulation have been adopted.

Alternatively, with reference to a request introduced through Harry Maguire’s defence for a postponement of the trial, the judges weren’t very lenient.

Postponement, particularly when a brand new felony staff is employed through the defence, is commonplace in Greek trials. It used to be now not mandatory, even though, and the pass judgement on used to be smartly inside his remit to reject it.

In some circumstances, judges make a decision to reject such requests for secondary causes, for instance to profit from witnesses provide within the court docket who may well be absent if the trial takes position a yr later, or just to steer clear of felony techniques of procrastination.

What did the defence say?

All through this primary level of the felony procedure, and pending the footballer’s enchantment, his defence staff didn’t persuade the judges.

England defender Maguire, his brother Joe, and circle of relatives pal Christopher Sharman denied the fees.

The defence centered closely on their account of ways an preliminary combat began within the alleyways of Mykonos with a bunch of Albanians.

Symbol copyright

Symbol caption

The alleged offences came about on 20 August – inside 5 days the 3 males were convicted

Ioannis Paradissis, a attorney for 2 of the policemen concerned, stated this used to be no defence for the fees for which Harry Maguire used to be accused. “They have got accidents and the 3 defendants say they aren’t accountable however… they do not provide an explanation for how those accidents have been made,” he instructed the BBC’s Nowadays Programme.

Forward of the decision, the footballer’s attorney, Andreas Anagnostakis, stated his consumer’s behavior used to be justified for the reason that policemen had allegedly attacked him in his “golden leg” and instructed him “your profession is over”.

Because it used to be in response to Harry Maguire’s phrases, the judges discovered this defence now not confirmed in court docket.

Consistent with the prosecution, the tried bribery rate concerned Harry Maguire asking whether or not he may just pay a tremendous to be launched from police custody.

His attorney didn’t utterly deny that, suggesting “it will were one thing that used to be misplaced in translation”.

What hope for his enchantment?

It’s unclear how lengthy that may take but it surely in most cases takes a yr from the instant an enchantment is lodged.

However in Greece an enchantment is in impact a retrial, consistent with Ioannis Paradissis.

“So clearly there’s nonetheless time for the 3 defendants to mention they’re sorry after which I consider that the end result may well be other.”

Symbol copyright
PA Media

Symbol caption

Maguire’s membership Manchester United have given a remark pronouncing the participant isn’t matter to any global trip restrictions

As Maguire’s membership, Manchester United, indicate, through accommodation an enchantment the decision has been quashed, the conviction nullified and he has neither a felony document neither is matter to any global trip restrictions.

Within the months prior to Harry Maguire’s enchantment, his defence staff will face a choice whether or not to offer a extra detailed rationalization of his innocence or settle for wrongdoing and apologise in trade for the fees to be dropped.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *