Western Digital gets sued for sneaking SMR disks into its NAS channel

Hattis Law isn't pulling any punches in the allegations made in its class-action lawsuit, specifically calling WD out not only for using SMR technology in less-than-ideal devices, but flatly accusing them of outright deception in the process.
Amplify / Hattis Legislation is not pulling any punches within the allegations made in its class-action lawsuit, in particular calling WD out no longer just for the usage of SMR generation in less-than-ideal gadgets, however flatly accusing them of outright deception within the procedure.

All 3 of the surviving standard laborious pressure distributors—Toshiba, Western Virtual, and Seagate—have got stuck sneaking disks that includes Shingled Magnetic Recording generation into surprising puts lately. However Western Virtual has been probably the most brazen of the 3, and it is been singled out for a category motion lawsuit in reaction.

Even though all 3 primary producers quietly added SMR disks to their desktop laborious pressure line-up, Western Virtual is the one one to this point to slide them into its NAS (Community Hooked up Garage) stack. NAS drives are anticipated to accomplish neatly in RAID and different a couple of disk arrays, whether or not ZFS swimming pools or client gadgets like Synology or Netgear NAS home equipment.

In sharp distinction to Western Virtual’s place on SMR disks as NAS, Seagate government Greg Belloni advised us that there were not any SMR disks within the Ironwolf (competitor to Western Virtual Purple) line-up now and that the generation isn’t suitable for that goal.

“Seagate simplest produces NAS drives which might be CMR,” Belloni says. “We shouldn’t have any SMR drives in our Ironwolf and Ironwolf Professional drives, which might be NAS answers […] we do not counsel SMR for NAS.”

Hattis Legislation has initiated a category motion lawsuit in opposition to Western Virtual, accordingly. The lawsuit alleges each that the SMR generation within the more moderen Western Virtual Purple drives is irrelevant for the advertised goal of the drives and that Western Virtual intentionally “deceived and hurt[ed] customers” during doing so.

Although Western Digital's 4TB SMR disk performed adequately in light duty tests, it performed miserably when used to replace a disk in a degraded four-disk RAIDz1 vdev.
Amplify / Even though Western Virtual’s 4TB SMR disk carried out adequately in mild accountability assessments, it carried out miserably when used to interchange a disk in a degraded four-disk RAIDz1 vdev.

Hattis’ place is reinforced via a sequence of assessments that web site ServeTheHome launched the day past. The effects show that even if Western Virtual’s new 4TB Purple “NAS” disk carried out adequately as a desktop pressure, it was once not worthy for goal in a ZFS garage array (zpool).

Even though Western Virtual does no longer, to the most productive of our wisdom, have an respectable coverage referring to alternative of Purple drives unknowingly bought with SMR, a number of readers have shared their particular person good fortune tales of having Western Virtual’s buyer care division to interchange such disks with non-SMR disks at no cost.

The ones curious about the entire main points might view the total textual content of Hattis Legislation’s category motion lawsuit right here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *